Smelting Charges Dispute: Why TNMM Was Preferred Over CUP in the PT S Decision?

Tax Court Appeal Decision | Annual Corporate Income Tax | Partially Granted

PUT-008746.15/2023/PP/M.IA Year 2025

Taxindo Prime Consulting
Tuesday, October 06, 2026 | 17:46 WIB
00:00
Optimized with Google Chrome
Smelting Charges Dispute: Why TNMM Was Preferred Over CUP in the PT S Decision?

PT S faced a major challenge when the tax authorities issued a significant adjustment on its operational costs paid to its Japanese affiliate. The core of the conflict lies in the selection of the transfer pricing method. The Respondent applied the CUP method by referencing global spot market prices, while PT S maintained the TNMM approach, which evaluates the net operating profit level. The Respondent argued that the S & R Charges were excessively high, thereby eroding the tax base in Indonesia.

Legal Resolution and Judicial Considerations

The legal resolution provided by the Tax Court emphasized the quality of comparable data. The Board of Judges opined that the CUP method requires an extremely high and strict level of comparability. Global spot market prices cannot be used as a direct benchmark for long-term processing service contracts without accurate functional adjustments. The Court's decision to partially grant the appeal carries the important implication that robust Transfer Pricing Documentation (TP Doc) is not a mere formality but a vital piece of evidence to justify costs in related-party transactions.

Conclusion

In conclusion, companies with complex affiliate transactions must ensure that the choice of transfer pricing method is supported by a deep comparability analysis rather than merely following industry trends.

A Comprehensive Analysis and the Tax Court Decision on This Dispute Are Available Here


November 13, 2026 • Taxindo Prime Consulting

Tax Court Appeal Decision | PPN | Fully Granted

PUT-118369.16/2014/PP/M.IIIA Year 2019

November 13, 2026 • Taxindo Prime Consulting

Tax Court Appeal Decision | PPN | Partially Granted

PUT-118365.16/2014/PP/M.IIIA Year 2019

November 13, 2026 • Taxindo Prime Consulting

Tax Court Appeal Decision | PPN | Fully Granted

PUT-117307.16/2015/PP/M.XIIIB Year 2019

November 13, 2026 • Taxindo Prime Consulting

Tax Court Appeal Decision | PPN | Fully Granted

PUT-116319.16/2014/PP/M.XIVA Year 2019

November 13, 2026 • Taxindo Prime Consulting

Tax Court Appeal Decision | PPN | Partially Granted

PUT-114242.16/2012/PP/M.IVB Year 2019

November 13, 2026 • Taxindo Prime Consulting

Tax Court Appeal Decision | Annual Corporate Income Tax | Fully Granted

PUT-114097.15/2014/PP/M.XB Year 2019

November 11, 2026 • Taxindo Prime Consulting

Tax Court Appeal Decision | PPN | Fully Granted

PUT-113924.16/2015/PP/M.XIVA Year 2019

November 11, 2026 • Taxindo Prime Consulting

Tax Court Appeal Decision | Income Tax Article 26 (Non-Final) | Fully Granted

PUT-113859.13/2011/PP/M.XIIA Year 2019

November 11, 2026 • Taxindo Prime Consulting

Tax Court Appeal Decision | Annual Corporate Income Tax | Fully Granted

PUT-113770.15/2014/PP/M.IA Year 2019

November 10, 2026 • Taxindo Prime Consulting

Tax Court Appeal Decision | PBB-P3 | Partially Granted

PUT-111899.18/2015/PP/M.IIIB Year 2019

Taxindo Prime Consulting (TPC) is a firm specializing in tax, accounting, business, and business law consulting.
Taxindo Prime Consulting (TPC) is established as a trusted strategic partner, providing comprehensive solutions in tax consulting, accounting, business development, and business law. Driven by a commitment to integrity and professionalism, TPC is dedicated to delivering more than just standard consultation; we provide education, tactical advice, and concrete solutions. Our services are meticulously designed to analyze and resolve clients' tax and business challenges with objectivity, in-depth insight, and full independence, ensuring both regulatory compliance and long-term business sustainability.
OFFICE
Mega Plaza Building 12th Floor
Jl. H.R. Rasuna Said Kav C-3 Jakarta 12940

Phone :
+62 21 521 2686
+62 817 001 3303

Email :
info@taxindo.co.id
Copyright © 2026 Taxindo Prime Consulting
Taxindo Prime Consulting
Tax and Transfer Pricing Calculator
Tax Calendar
×
Newsletter