This dispute focuses on the classification of coal transportation services as public transport services exempted from VAT under Article 4A paragraph (3) letter j of the VAT Law jo. PMK 80/PMK.03/2012. The Respondent (DGT) issued a correction, arguing that the activity constituted specialized transportation services of an exclusive nature, thus subject to VAT.
The Respondent contended that coal is a mining product requiring specialized transport facilities under transportation regulations, making its delivery a Taxable Service. However, the Petitioner (PT TMS) materially proven that the fleet used consisted of vehicles with yellow-base plates and black lettering, which legally serves as the identity for public transportation for passengers and/or goods.
In its legal considerations, the Board of Judges emphasized that the primary determinant for the VAT-exempt facility in land transport is the use of yellow plate vehicles. The fact that PT TMS provided transportation based on routes and was not an exclusive vehicle rental service further strengthened the Petitioner's position. The Board of Judges revoked the Respondent's correction as the objective criteria for public transport services were met.
This ruling provides legal certainty for logistics companies that the use of yellow plates is strong evidence of public transport status. The implication is that as long as a company can prove the use of a yellow plate fleet and a compensation structure based on weight/distance (not time-based rental), the non-VAT facility remains applicable even if the commodity is specific, such as coal.
A Comprehensive Analysis and the Tax Court Decision on This Dispute Are Available Here
tpc.consulting 
tpc.consulting 
info@taxindo.co.id