Functional risk profile classification serves as a primary determinant in assessing the arm's length principle during tax audits in Indonesia. In the case of PT Toyota Boshoku Indonesia (TBI), the Respondent issued a significant correction of IDR 210 billion by reclassifying the Petitioner from a licensed manufacturer to a contract manufacturer to justify different comparable sets.
The core of the conflict lay in the comparability analysis methodology where the Respondent rejected the Petitioner's chosen comparables and utilized single-year data. The Petitioner firmly defended its business profile and demonstrated that the 2019 losses were a systemic impact of the national automotive industry downturn, rather than transfer pricing manipulation. Another crucial argument was that the affiliated transactions were domestic, meaning there was no economic substance for national tax base erosion.
The Board of Judges sided with the Petitioner, stating that the Respondent failed to prove any deviation from the arm's length principle. The Board emphasized the importance of consistency in determining risk profiles and acknowledged that operational losses could stem from external market factors. Consequently, this decision strengthens the Taxpayer's position in using multi-year data.
This ruling stresses that tax authorities must exercise caution when applying Article 18 paragraph (3) of the Income Tax Law to domestic transactions where tax arbitrage opportunities are non-existent. PT TBI’s victory serves as a reminder that a comprehensive economic analysis of market conditions is a variable that cannot be ignored in transfer pricing testing.
tpc.consulting 
tpc.consulting 
info@taxindo.co.id