Disputes over the creditability of Input Tax for newly established Taxable Entrepreneurs (PKP) often arise during tax audits, particularly concerning the interpretation of Article 9 Paragraph (8) Letter j of the VAT Law regarding capital goods limitations. The case of PT II (385 - PUT-118369.16/2014/PP/M.IIIA Year 2019) provides legal clarity that production activities for self-use, such as display goods, constitute concrete evidence that a company has commenced production. The Respondent performed a positive correction on Input Tax, arguing that the Petitioner had not made any commercial delivery (export) when the goods were acquired, thus deeming non-capital Input Tax non-creditable. However, the Petitioner successfully demonstrated through daily production reports that they had produced tractor units since October 2013 for marketing purposes.
The Board of Judges delivered a progressive legal consideration by referring to Government Regulation (PP) Number 1 of 2012, which states that self-use for productive purposes is a taxable delivery. The legal logic follows that if a delivery has occurred (even for self-use), the "not yet in production" status is automatically invalidated. This ruling reaffirms that the right to credit Input Tax does not necessarily depend on third-party sales but begins once productive activities generating taxable goods commence. Consequently, Taxpayers must strengthen internal documentation during the pre-commercial phase to protect their tax credit rights from rigid administrative corrections.
A Comprehensive Analysis and the Tax Court Decision on This Dispute Are Available Here