Legal certainty regarding the authority to represent a company in tax disputes has once again become a critical focus in a recent Tax Court Decision. The case of PT KE reflects a fatal risk for Taxpayers when undergoing board changes during the appeal submission period. A dispute that was intended to examine the merits of VAT corrections on CPO deliveries to Bonded Zones ended prematurely due to a lack of synchronization between internal corporate administration and the timing of legal document submissions.
The conflict centered on the signing of an appeal letter by a former director who had been dismissed via a Circular Resolution of Shareholders, yet whose name remained listed in the Ministry of Law and Human Rights (Kemenkumham) database at the time of signing. The Taxpayer argued that as long as the change had not been officially accepted by the Ministry, the former director maintained legal capacity toward the public. However, the tax authority identified a loophole: the right to represent the company is extinguished the moment the shareholders' resolution is made, regardless of when state administrative processes are completed.
In its deliberation, the Tax Court Panel of Judges emphasized that the legal relationship between directors and a company is internal and contractual, governed by the Law on Limited Liability Companies. Once the shareholders' meeting (RUPS) confirms a dismissal, all public authority of said director, including the power to sign tax appeal letters, is declared void. The Judges rejected the "publicity principle" of the Kemenkumham database as a basis for signature legality, subsequently declaring the appeal inadmissible due to formal defects. This case serves as a critical alarm for corporate management to ensure real-time coordination between legal and tax teams so that any changes in management are documented and updated before initiating litigation.
A Comprehensive Analysis and the Tax Court Decision on This Dispute Are Available Here