Intra-group service and intangible property disputes remain a central issue in Indonesian transfer pricing audits. The case of PT KBI highlights the tax authority's tendency to view subsidiaries as independent entities that should not require technical assistance from their parent company. The Respondent argued that as a fully-fledged manufacturer, PT KBI should possess the internal capability to manage its production without paying royalties or technical fees.
However, the court proceedings revealed a different industrial reality. The Board of Judges emphasized that technology and design ownership remain at the global level. The Respondent's failure to perform a detailed functional analysis became a significant weakness in their correction. The Judges viewed royalty and technical service fees not as a mere profit shift, but as an operational necessity to maintain strict automotive quality standards. The Taxpayer's victory in this post underscores the importance of physical and digital service output evidence as a defense against allegations of sham transactions.
'A Comprehensive Analysis and the Tax Court Decision on This Dispute Are Available Here'