Administrative errors in filling out tax payment forms often lead to the rejection of tax credits by the Directorate General of Taxes (DGT). In the PT AI dispute, the Respondent corrected the entire Income Tax Article 26 credit for the November 2011 period because the State Receipt Evidence (BPN) listed the Japanese company’s name instead of PT AI’s name as the withholder. Consequently, the DGT’s administrative system assumed PT AI had not paid the withheld tax, leading to a significant double tax burden.
The heart of this conflict is the absolute application of PER-38/PJ/2009 without considering the actual tax facts. The Appellant provided strong evidence in the form of accounting journals, bank statements, and data reconciliation showing that the funds entering the state treasury originated from their assets. The error in the name entered by the remitting bank was considered a clerical oversight that should have been clarified through comprehensive audit mechanisms, rather than an immediate positive correction.
The Board of Judges delivered a fair ruling, stating that as long as the money is proven to have entered the state account and is directly related to the reported transaction, the right to a tax credit cannot be revoked. This resolution highlights the importance for tax auditors not to rely solely on "data matching" on a monitor, but to conduct deep material evidence testing. Implicitly, Taxpayers are granted legal protection against non-substantial administrative errors.