Disputes regarding the Corporate Income Tax (CIT) rate for Coal Mining Business Work Agreement (PKP2B) holders often hinge on the dichotomy between "nailed-down" contract schemes and domestic tax laws. The Respondent argued that the progressive rate of up to 30% in the contract must remain applicable. However, the Board of Judges examined Article 14 of the PKP2B, which stipulates that if the Indonesian Government sets a lower tax rate, the contractor is entitled to that rate. The reduction of the CIT rate to a flat 25% via Law Number 36 of 2008 is a clear manifestation of a government policy providing a lower rate nationally. Consequently, the application of the 25% rate by PT PI is legally valid as the contract itself allows for the adoption of more favorable tax rates.
A Comprehensive Analysis and the Tax Court Decision on This Dispute Are Available Here