Tax authorities often issue corrections based on raw data from information exchanges with the Directorate General of Customs and Excise without examining the factual status of the documents. In the PT LOC case, the Respondent issued a VAT export base correction of IDR 1.15 billion simply because they found Export Declaration (PEB) numbers not reported in the VAT Return, even though no physical delivery occurred.
The conflict centered on the discrepancy between administrative data in the DGT's automated system and the legal reality on the ground. The Respondent insisted that every validated PEB must be treated as a taxable delivery and rejected new evidence of export cancellation, citing Article 26A paragraph (4) of the KUP Law. Conversely, the Taxpayer successfully proved that the goods never left the customs area and possessed official cancellation approval from the Customs authorities.
The Board of Judges resolved the case by prioritizing the principle of material truth. The Board emphasized that the essence of VAT is a tax on consumption or delivery of goods. If an export is legally cancelled through valid customs mechanisms, there is no taxable object. Formal requirements regarding document submission during audits cannot negate the fact that the transaction never took place.
This ruling provides legal certainty that inter-agency data exchange is not absolute if the Taxpayer can provide authoritative evidence to the contrary. It underscores the importance of administrative integration between logistics, customs, and tax departments within a company to prevent similar disputes.