The rejection of Input Tax credits for transactions deemed "Not Based on Actual Transactions" (TBTS) is a significant concern for bona fide taxpayers. In this case, the DGT corrected all Input Tax from PT GPP, alleging the vendor was on a "suspect list" for issuing fictitious tax invoices. The core conflict lay in using "indicated" status as a legal basis to annul a taxpayer's constitutional right to credit taxes. The Board of Judges provided a pivotal resolution: an indication or a proposal to be blacklisted is not valid legal evidence to allege a fictitious transaction if not supported by field audits or a final criminal court ruling. As the Petitioner demonstrated concrete evidence of payment and receipt of goods, the IDR 888 million correction was overturned. Consequently, legal protection for taxpayers with complete transaction documentation remains robust, even if their vendors face tax issues in the future.