PT SRI (the Applicant) successfully won a tax dispute regarding the negative correction of the VAT Base (DPP) on the utilization of Intangible Taxable Goods from outside the customs area. The dispute stemmed from differing royalty calculation methodologies between the Taxpayer and the tax authority (the Respondent), where the Respondent adjusted royalty expenses in the Corporate Income Tax return, which subsequently affected the VAT Base.
The core conflict lay in the Respondent's view, which only recognized royalty expenses at 3% of sales where raw materials originated from affiliated parties, assuming that the Know-How was embedded in those materials. Conversely, the Applicant argued that the Know-How from Sakae Riken Kogyo (SRK) Japan was used for the entire production process in Indonesia regardless of the raw material source; thus, the 3% royalty on total sales was valid, and VAT had been paid according to the transaction facts.
The Board of Judges provided a resolution by considering that the utilization of such technology covered the company's entire production process, not just limited to raw materials from affiliates. The judges assessed that the Applicant was proven to have utilized Intangible Taxable Goods and had correctly fulfilled the obligation to collect and remit VAT to the state treasury based on the available documentary evidence.
Analysis of this decision shows that VAT corrections dependent on Corporate Income Tax corrections (related to transfer pricing) must be based on strong material evidence regarding the utilization of such intangible assets. In conclusion, the Board of Judges overturned the Respondent's correction because the Applicant's calculation was deemed more consistent with the prevailing economic and legal realities.
A Comprehensive Analysis and the Tax Court Decision on This Dispute Are Available Here
tpc.consulting 
tpc.consulting 
info@taxindo.co.id