The tax authority issued a significant correction to the Article 22 Income Tax base for the October 2019 tax period against PT SPS, arguing that the entity is an industrial business required to withhold tax on agricultural purchases. The issue of Business Classification (KLU) and the definition of "manufacturing process" became the focal point of this dispute, where the use of mechanical dryers was considered by the Respondent as an industrial activity creating mechanical value-add.
The conflict arose when the Respondent classified PT SPS as an industry based on the ownership of large-capacity drying machines and electricity consumption exceeding 200 kVa. According to the Respondent, under PMK-34/PMK.010/2017, industrial entities must withhold 0.25% Article 22 Income Tax from corn purchases. Conversely, PT SPS maintained they are wholesalers (KLU 46201) who perform drying solely for quality preservation and standardization, without altering the physical or chemical nature of the corn. PT SPS also highlighted the risk of double taxation if forced to withhold, as their sales to feedmills are already subject to withholding by the buyers.
The Board of Judges, in their consideration, acknowledged that technically under the Industrial Law, processes providing new utility could be categorized as industry. However, the Board found inconsistencies in the Respondent's position, which continued to recognize PT SPS's KLU as "Wholesale" for Corporate Income Tax purposes and accepted Article 22 withholding slips from PT SPS's customers. The Board emphasized that in tax law, equity must prevail over rigid legal certainty. Forcing PT SPS to act as a withholding agent would result in administrative unfairness and an economic double burden inconsistent with the philosophy of efficient taxation.
This decision has significant implications for agricultural commodity players, showing that KLU formality and consistent tax treatment by authorities across different tax types can be key evidence in court. PT SPS's victory confirms that trade-supporting activities (such as drying) do not automatically change a taxpayer's status to "industry" if the primary function remains distribution and wholesale trade.
A Comprehensive Analysis and the Tax Court Decision on This Dispute Are Available Here
tpc.consulting 
tpc.consulting 
info@taxindo.co.id