This tax dispute originated from a positive fiscal adjustment of all PT PNR’s business expenses totaling IDR 23.7 billion by the tax authorities, who deemed the costs non-deductible as they were related to non-taxable income. The tax authorities argued that based on the Audited Financial Statements, PT PNR only recorded income from joint venture shares and interest, thus the matching cost against revenue principle prohibited the deduction of operational expenses.
However, PT PNR countered by emphasizing that the income was merely an accounting entry based on the equity method under PSAK 15, not a realized cash dividend. During the trial, it was revealed that there were no General Meeting of Shareholders (GMS) resolutions or cash inflows proving a dividend distribution from the investee entities to PT PNR in 2018. The Panel of Judges agreed that without the realization of a legal dividend distribution event, the company's operational costs remained valid and deductible business expenses.
The Panel of Judges ultimately cancelled the entire correction because the basis for the adjustment—the existence of non-taxable income—was factually unproven for the relevant tax year. This decision reinforces the importance of separating accounting profit recognition (equity method) from legal and fiscal dividend realization when determining the deductibility of business costs.
A Comprehensive Analysis and the Tax Court Decision on This Dispute Are Available Here
tpc.consulting 
tpc.consulting 
info@taxindo.co.id